Unverified

ChatGPT 5.6 Sol Helps Rule Out Ellipticity-Only Gradient Estimates in Dimension Three

Nam Q. Le, Qi Sun, and Hung V. Tran construct bounded smooth solutions of uniformly elliptic nondivergence-form equations in dimension three whose gradient L1 norms diverge, ruling out ellipticity-only interior W1p estimates for all p at least one; they credit ChatGPT 5.6 Sol with the key strategies and report reworking and checking the arguments themselves.

Report typeCounterexample
Reported byNam Q. Le, Qi Sun, Hung V. Tran
ModelsChatGPT 5.6 Sol
Source dateAug 13, 2026

In a preprint first uploaded on August 13, 2026, Nam Q. Le, Qi Sun, and Hung V. Tran resolve negatively an open regularity question for uniformly elliptic equations in nondivergence form. They construct smooth, uniformly elliptic coefficient matrices and bounded smooth solutions in dimension three whose gradients have unbounded L1L^1 norm, despite common Dirichlet data and a fixed ellipticity ratio.

More precisely, their sequence satisfies I≤Am≤281II\leq A_m\leq 2^{81}I, Am:D2um=0A_m:D^2u_m=0, and ∥um∥L∞≤1\lVert u_m\rVert_{L^\infty}\leq1, while ∥Dum∥L1\lVert Du_m\rVert_{L^1} tends to infinity. This rules out interior W1,pW^{1,p} estimates depending only on ellipticity for every p≥1p\geq1 in dimensions at least three. The construction also yields a uniformly convergent limit that is not locally of bounded variation for a measurable uniformly elliptic coefficient field.

The authors state that the main results arose through chats with ChatGPT 5.6 Sol and that ChatGPT supplied the key strategies. They report entirely reworking and rewriting the article, checking and simplifying every argument, and accepting responsibility for the result. The paper does not claim that the explicit ellipticity ratio 2812^{81} is optimal.

Coming soon

Organizer

Boyuan Wang portraitBoyuan Wang
Minghan Wang portraitMinghan Wang
Bochao Li portraitBochao Li
Hongwei Hu portraitHongwei Hu